Memo Pad: Take That... Get Those Virtual Ad Dollars... No Pressure

The famous book critic is also "famously busy and famously rude"; he is "pale and bloated," the "vitriolic scourge of writers, artists and musicians."

TAKE THAT!: The famous book critic is also "famously busy and famously rude"; he is "pale and bloated," the "vitriolic scourge of writers, artists and musicians."

Few would come forward to claim a likeness to this character from Cathleen Schine's serialized murder mystery in The New York Times Magazine, who is expected at an artists' colony but instead shows up as a beached corpse. But notoriously acerbic Vanity Fair columnist James Wolcott did, on his blog last week. And as in any good mystery, there's a motive, though Wolcott didn't mention it then: In a 2004 Vanity Fair story on Schine and her ex-husband, New Yorker film critic David Denby, Wolcott said aspects of a Schine novel were "hackneyed" and "generic," and compared it to a "Lifetime movie shot through a milk-bottle lens."

Like Schine's fictional "culture thug" who "murder[s] people's work," Wolcott lacks a college diploma, but the character may only be a composite — the critic in the story also has a TV career and doubles as a "sycophantic" celebrity profiler.

Schine declined comment, but Wolcott wrote WWD in an e-mail, "I suspect Cathy wasn't too thrilled with my pan of her novel...and decided to bump me off fiction-wise to repay me for my sins.

"I'm in favor of literary feuds and score-settling being played out like a Jacobean drama in the slick pages of The New York Times Magazine. But I do think she might have given her critic-corpse a scene or two instead of serving him up like cold mashed potatoes." Which is, perhaps, the best revenge of all. — Irin Carmon

GET THOSE VIRTUAL AD DOLLARS: It's no news Hearst Magazines has had a busy year on the digital front — but its Cosmogirl title is the only one so far to go into the virtual world. And, no, the editors don't just want their own avatars: According to new data from eMarketer, by 2011, 53 percent of children and teen Internet users will enter a virtual world at least once a month. So to reach that demographic, Cosmogirl has partnered with established virtual Web site, where readers will be able to enter the Cosmogirl Global Village.
Page:  Next »
load comments


Sign in using your Facebook or Twitter account, or simply type your comment below as a guest by entering your email and name. Your email address will not be shared. Please note that WWD reserves the right to remove profane, distasteful or otherwise inappropriate language.
News from WWD

Sign upSign up for WWD and FN newsletters to receive daily headlines, breaking news alerts and weekly industry wrap-ups.

getIsArchiveOnly= hasAccess=false hasArchiveAccess=false