"Department stores’ great strength was as providers of credit, but that hasn’t been the case since the introduction of the walk-around credit card 50 years ago. Even when revenues were steady or growing, they’ve been losing market share, giving up about one-third of it in the Eighties alone. They’re great institutions that no longer have the importance they once had.
"This Federated-May thing has been pretty much an annual rumor, but I attach importance to every rumor, and this one would make a lot of sense. Even when you look at the two companies’ overlap geographically, it’s not as serious as you might think — just a few markets, including southern California."
Federated is strong on the East and West Coasts and in the Southeast, while May is strong on the West Coast, in Texas and parts of the Northeast and Midwest.
Illustrating Solomon’s point about market share, retail consultant Jack Schafer, of Jack Schafer Associates in San Francisco, cited U.S. Commerce Department statistics that showed department stores losing market share, as a percentage of nonautomobile sales, for seven straight years through 2001, the last full year for which figures were available. Department stores peaked with a 12.8 percent share in 1993 and 1994 but have since declined steadily, to 10.2 percent in 2001.
Most analysts don’t see any major bankruptcies on the horizon, though they do see plenty of store closings, with retailers weeding out unprofitable units. Simultaneously, retailing increasingly becomes a game of scale, making consolidation likely.