"It's a funny thing, because if he had finished the play when he first started writing it a while ago, I probably would have been Charles [the youngest brother]," grins Hamilton, 38, over a soy latte at 'SNice in the West Village. "You don't necessarily think of yourself as getting older, but every once in a while these little markers come along and you're like, 'Oh, I'm reading for the father, not the kid.'"
Though not a patriarch in the literal sense, Hamilton, as Teddy, certainly fulfills the necessary parental duties. Set in a New York apartment, "Things We Want" shows three brothers — Charles (Paul Dano), Sty (Peter Dinklage) and Teddy — whose parents committed suicide years ago. They're now living together in an alcohol-fueled maelstrom of pain and discontent, masked under the cloak of witty repartee. At the play's outset, Charles has just dropped out of culinary school and suffered a broken heart; Teddy is an acolyte to a self-help guru named Dr. Miracle, and Sty is glued to the sofa in a state of uninterrupted inebriation. Things quickly devolve as characters either rectify their lives or sink into a deeper abyss.
Directed by Ethan Hawke, "Things We Want" proves a reunion of sorts. Hamilton first met Sherman when they were both 18 and he dropped out of college to star in the latter's breakout work "Women and Wallace" at the Young Playwrights Horizons. A few years later, the duo, along with Hawke, founded The Malaparte Theater Company.
"When people know each other really well they can say, 'Oh, you know that thing you do? That little trick? Don't do that,'" says Hamilton of being directed by Hawke, with whom he costarred in last year's "The Coast of Utopia." "For me it was hard because the comfort level works both ways, where I would say things or speak up in ways that I might not have with a director I didn't know as well. I might have overstepped my bounds. I could see him thinking, 'Hey, who's directing this play?'"